Bukhari & Ibn Mujahid

Ibn Mujahid’s System for Choosing Authentic Qira’at

Introduction to Qira’at

Qira’at refers to the various methods of reciting the Quran. Each method has its own unique pronunciation, intonation, and sometimes even slight variations in wording. The science of Qira’at is crucial for preserving the Quran’s integrity and ensuring that it is transmitted accurately.

Ibn Mujahid’s Background

Abu Bakr Ahmad ibn Musa ibn al-Abbas ibn Mujahid al-Atashi (Arabic: أبو بكر أحمد بن موسى بن العباس بن مجاهد التميمي, romanized: Abū Bakr Aḥmad ibn Mūsā ibn al-ʿAbbās Ibn Mujāhid al-ʿAṭashī, 859/860 C.E.– 936 C.E.) was an Islamic scholar most notable for establishing and delineating the seven canonical Quranic readings (qira’at) in his work Kitāb al-sabʿa fī l-qirāʾāt.

Ibn Mujahid was a prominent Islamic scholar who played a significant role in the field of Quranic recitation. He is best known for his systematic approach to identifying and authenticating the different Qira’at of the Quran.

The Criteria for Authenticity

Ibn Mujahid established specific criteria to determine which Qira’at could be considered authentic. His methodology involved several key steps:

Chain of Transmission (Isnad):

Ibn Mujahid emphasized the importance of a reliable chain of transmission for each Qira’a. This means that each recitation must be traced back through trustworthy scholars to the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). The integrity of the narrators in this chain is crucial.

Conformity with Uthmanic Codex:

The recitations had to align with the Uthmanic codex, which is the standardized version of the Quran compiled during Caliph Uthman’s reign. Any variation that contradicted this codex was scrutinized closely.

Widespread Acceptance (Mutaba’at):

A Qira’a needed to have widespread acceptance among scholars and practitioners within the Muslim community. This included being taught by reputable teachers and practiced by many individuals across different regions.

Linguistic Validity:

The recitations had to adhere to Arabic linguistic rules and grammar, ensuring that they were not only correct but also eloquent and meaningful within the context of classical Arabic.

Consistency with Tafsir (Interpretation):

Ibn Mujahid also considered whether a particular Qira’a was consistent with established interpretations (Tafsir) of Quranic verses, ensuring that it did not lead to misinterpretations or contradictions in meaning.

The Selection Process Based on these criteria,

Ibn Mujahid selected seven primary Qira’at that he deemed authentic:

The Medinese reader Nafiʽ
The Meccan reader Ibn Kathir.
The Damascene reader Ibn Amir.
The Basran reader Abu Amr.
The Kufan reader Al-Kisa’i.
The Kufan reader Hamzah az-Zaiyyat.
The Kufan reader Aasim ibn Abi al-Najud.

These seven reciters became widely recognized as authoritative sources for Quranic recitation.

Arabic Terminology Related to Qira’at Science Understanding some key Arabic terms related to this science can help clarify its concepts:

Qira’a (قراءة): Recitation.
Qari’ (قارئ): A person who recites.
Isnad (إسناد): Chain of narration.
Mutaba’at (متابعة): Conformity or agreement.
Uthmanic Codex (المصحف العثماني): The standardized text of the Quran compiled under Caliph Uthman.
Tafsir (تفسير): Interpretation or explanation of Quranic verses.
Rasm (رسم): The script or orthography used in writing the Quran.

Conclusion

Ibn Mujahid’s systematic approach laid down foundational principles for evaluating and preserving authentic methods of Quranic recitation, which continue to influence how Muslims engage with their holy text today.

---

The System of Bukhari for Choosing Authentic Hadiths

Bukhari’s Background

Abū ʿAbd Allāh Muḥammad ibn Ismāʿīl ibn Ibrāhīm al-Juʿfī al-Bukhārī
(Arabic: أبو عبد الله محمد بن إسماعيل بن إبرهيم الجعفي البخاري)
21 July 810 C.E. – 1 September 870 C.E.) was a 9th-century Persian Muslim muhaddith who is widely regarded as the most important hadith scholar in the history of Sunni Islam. Al-Bukhari’s extant works include the hadith collection Sahih al-Bukhari, al-Tarikh al-Kabir, and al-Adab al-Mufrad.

Born in Bukhara in present-day Uzbekistan, Al-Bukhari began learning hadith at a young age. He travelled across the Abbasid Caliphate and learned under several influential contemporary scholars. Bukhari memorized thousands of hadith narrations, compiling the Sahih al-Bukhari in 846. He spent the rest of his life teaching the hadith he had collected.

Introduction to Hadith and Its Importance Hadith refers to the recorded sayings, actions, and approvals of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). These narrations are crucial in Islamic teachings as they provide context and elaboration on the Quranic text. The science of hadith (علم الحديث) is dedicated to studying these narrations to determine their authenticity.
He was a prominent Islamic scholar who dedicated his life to collecting and authenticating hadiths. His work, “Sahih al-Bukhari,” is considered one of the most reliable collections of hadith in Sunni Islam.

Criteria for Authenticity
Bukhari developed a rigorous methodology for selecting authentic hadiths. His criteria can be summarized as follows:

Chain of Narrators (Isnad):
Bukhari emphasized the importance of a reliable chain of narrators leading back to the Prophet Muhammad. Each narrator must be known for their integrity (عدالة) and precision (ضبط).

Direct Connection:
The narrators in the chain must have met each other directly. This ensures that there is no gap in transmission.

Reputation and Integrity:
Each narrator must possess a good reputation among scholars, meaning they should not have been known for lying or committing major sins.

Consistency with Other Narrations:
A hadith must not contradict established facts or other authentic narrations. If it does, it raises questions about its authenticity.

Absence of Hidden Defects (‘Illah):
Bukhari examined each narration for any hidden defects that could undermine its reliability, even if it appeared sound at first glance.

The Process of Verification
Bukhari’s process involved extensive travel across various regions such as Iraq, Egypt, and the Hijaz to meet scholars and collect hadiths. He would scrutinize each narration meticulously before including it in his collection.

Personal Interviews:
He often conducted personal interviews with narrators to assess their character and memory.

Cross-referencing:
Bukhari cross-referenced narrations from multiple sources to ensure consistency and reliability.

Final Selection:
Out of hundreds of thousands of hadiths he encountered, only about 7,275 were included in “Sahih al-Bukhari,” with around 2,600 unique hadiths that are not repeated.

Arabic Terminology Related to Hadith Science
Understanding some key Arabic terms used in the science of hadith can enhance comprehension:

Hadith (حديث): A report or narration regarding the sayings or actions of Prophet Muhammad.

Sahih (صحيح): Authentic; refers to a hadith that meets all criteria set by scholars like Bukhari.

Da’if (ضعيف): Weak; refers to a hadith that does not meet authenticity standards due to issues in its chain or content.

Hasan (حسن): Good; refers to a hadith that is acceptable but may have minor weaknesses.

Isnad (إسناد): The chain of narrators through whom a hadith has been transmitted.

Mutaba’at (متابعة): Supporting evidence from other narrations that corroborate a particular hadith.

‘Ilal (علل): Hidden defects that may affect the authenticity of a narration.

In summary, Imam Bukhari’s meticulous approach combined rigorous criteria for evaluating chains of transmission with thorough verification processes led him to compile one of the most respected collections of authentic hadiths in Islamic history.

---

Differences between Bukhari in Hadith and Ibn Mujahid in Qiraat on their Authentication System

To understand the differences between the authentication systems applied by Imam Bukhari in Hadith and Ibn Mujahid in Qiraat, we need to analyze their methodologies, criteria for authenticity, and the contexts within which they operated.

1. Contextual Background

Imam Bukhari (d. 256 AH) is renowned for his compilation of Hadith, which are sayings, actions, and approvals of the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ). His work, “Sahih al-Bukhari,” is considered one of the most authentic collections of Hadith in Sunni Islam.

Ibn Mujahid (d. 324 AH), on the other hand, is known for his work on Qira’at (the various readings of the Qur’an). He played a crucial role in canonizing seven canonical readings of the Qur’an that were accepted by scholars and practitioners.

2. Methodology of Authentication

Bukhari’s Authentication System:

Rigorous Criteria: Imam Bukhari established a very strict set of criteria for accepting Hadith as authentic. This included:

Chain of Narration (Isnad): Each narrator in the chain must be trustworthy (‘Adl) and have a strong memory (Dabt).
Continuity of Chain: The chain must be uninterrupted; each narrator must have directly heard from their predecessor.
Content Agreement: The content of the Hadith must not contradict established Islamic principles or other authentic narrations.
Personal Verification: Bukhari personally met many narrators and verified their reliability through direct questioning and observation.

Ibn Mujahid’s Authentication System:

Focus on Recitation: Ibn Mujahid’s approach was centered around the recitation of the Qur’an rather than oral transmission like Hadith. His criteria included:

Transmission from Recognized Authorities: The readings had to be transmitted from well-known readers who were recognized for their expertise.
Conformity with Uthmanic Codex: The readings had to align with the text established during Caliph Uthman’s time.
Limited Canonization: Ibn Mujahid limited his canonization to seven readings based on what he deemed widely accepted among scholars, but he did not apply an exhaustive verification process akin to Bukhari’s.

3. Nature of Content Being Authenticated

Hadith Content: In Hadith literature, content can include legal rulings, ethical teachings, or historical accounts attributed to the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ). Thus, authenticity is critical because it affects Islamic law and practice.

Qira’at Content: In contrast, Qira’at focuses specifically on how verses of the Qur’an are recited. Variations may arise due to dialectical differences or slight textual variations but do not typically alter fundamental beliefs or practices.

4. Impact on Islamic Scholarship

Bukhari’s Influence: The rigorous standards set by Bukhari have led to a high level of trust in his collection among Sunni Muslims. His methodology has influenced subsequent scholars’ approaches to Hadith authentication.

Ibn Mujahid’s Influence: While Ibn Mujahid’s work helped standardize Qur’anic recitation practices, it also allowed for some diversity within accepted readings. His influence remains significant among those studying Qira’at but does not carry the same weight as Bukhari’s impact on Hadith scholarship.

In summary, while both figures aimed at preserving Islamic teachings through their respective fields—Hadith for Bukhari and Qira’at for Ibn Mujahid—their authentication systems differ significantly in methodology, focus areas, and implications for Islamic scholarship.

The authentication system applied by Imam Bukhari in Hadith is characterized by rigorous criteria focusing on chain integrity and content agreement, while Ibn Mujahid’s system in Qira’at emphasizes recognized authority transmission aligned with Uthmanic codex without exhaustive verification like Bukhari’s approach.